Skip to content

FREE SHIPPING $75+ ORDERS! Click for details and exclusions.

Mann-Leigh Grilled Cheese for National Grilled Cheese Day

Mann-Leigh Grilled Cheese

Grilled cheese was a staple growing up in my house - it was always made the same way: in a skillet, with copious amounts of salted butter and always consisted of just two ingredients: processed violent yellow cheese product and honey top wheat bread. While I still have some fond memories in my heart for this fair, I'm glad it's not the staple in our home.

Here is how we do it in the Mann-Leigh household:

Mann-Leigh Grilled Cheese

Crunchy, buttery, cheesy goodness with the tang of sauce.



  • Thinly slice your onions.
  • Dice the Gouda into small cubes. It is best to do this while the cheese is cold. Place the cheese into a bowl and add the Somethin' Somethin' Sauce, tossing the cheese with the sauce. Set aside and allow to come to room temperature.
  • Slice your bread to your desired thickness if it isn't already sliced! Try to be uniform in thickness. Lay the bread out on your cutting board and heavily butter, edged to edge, one side of each piece.
  • Add your thinly sliced onions, dry, to a skillet and place the skillet over medium-high heat. Adding the onions dry will force the onions to cook using their own sugars, allowing for a better caramelization and sweeter onion. Never heat a dry or empty skillet!
  • Watch the skillet, stirring fairly often so the onions do not burn. Let the onions caramelize down, moving them around fairly often as not to burn them. The pan will get a bit brown on the bottom, but as long as the onions aren't burning, its fine. This should take approximately 20 minutes, with the need to stir increasing as it goes.
  • Once your onions are nice and browned, reduce heat to medium and add a tablespoon of butter. Stir to bring the onions and the butter together. Now add your balsamic vinegar and let cook. This will take a few minutes and you need to watch the pan. The vinegar will caramelize down even further and you will be left with a buttery, tangy and sweet onion.
  • Place a piece of bread, butter side down in the pan.
  • Add a smear of Somethin' Somethin' Sauce to the bread, then place a tablespoon of caramelized onions on top of it.
  • Now add the cheese cubes, piling it high on the bread. If some falls over, dont worry! melted cheese on a skillet is a perfect addition to this dish and will flip with the sandwich.
  • Cap the pile of cheese with another slice of buttered bread.
  • Cover your skillet to ensure that your cheese cubes melt.
  • Carefully press down on the top piece of bread to push the sandwich together, then flip it. It may take two hands.
  • Cover your skillet again and let it good to your desired crispness.
  • You may have to add more butter. Oh the humanity!
  • When I serve grilled cheese, I like to let it set up for a three minutes or so prior to cutting on the angle, or however the bread speaks to you!
Older Post
Newer Post
Close (esc)


Use this popup to embed a mailing list sign up form. Alternatively use it as a simple call to action with a link to a product or a page.

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.


Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Shop now